Opinions

Steve Davies-Russell

I agree that the present test is unworkable and should be renegotiated. A new improved test is, I believe, vital if the breed is to keep it's image intact. The test needs to be both achievable and credible if it is to be attractive to show handlers.

The test should not reflect trials, as it does at present, because trials are competitive by nature and require skills and a degree of training, clearly beyond the average owner. The test should set out to demonstrate the dogs only. The objectives should be clearly defined so that the assessors are in no doubt. The test should reflect everyday practical shepherding as closely as possible.

My suggestion is thus;

An outrun, a lift and fetch of about 200 yards. (emphasis should not be on the shape of the outrun or on how straight the fetch is). The dog should be able to gather sheep without undue stress and balance and control with a definite will to please being demonstrated. Sheep should then be held to the handler for inspection (the handler should move around sheep in both directions leaving the dog to head and hold the sheep as necessary.) The sheep should then be driven back to the top of the field and the dog called off. (If preferred the sheep could be penned or driven through a gate into another field.)

Other important considerations are:-

1. Sheep should be of a reasonable type. (ewes preferred).
2. The assessors should have some experience of the show world (at least one).
3. There should be no age limit (6 months onwards).
4. No prior qualifications.
5. No limit on number of tests.
6. Success in the test should be recognised as a qualification in dogs other than Champions.

I hope this has been of some use and would appreciated any information on developments.

Yours faithfully,
Steve Davies-Russell